Yeah, I took the rest of my birthday off, it seemed silly to spend it typing a review of a movie even I’m not that curious to hear my thoughts on. To be honest, my cultural intake (books, comics, TV, even the occasional film) is rather high right now, I suspect I’m just going to have to accept that some of it will escape unreviewed.
However, since I bothered to do a pre-show blog about Watchmen (I would give you a link, but it’s on the broken site), I kinda feel I’d be letting myself down if I don’t at least throw out a quick paragraph about the actual movie.
So, yeah, it’s pretty long.
The Watchmen movie as a whole has been met with a combination of apathy and outright hostility for the most part, with even the postive reviews having to include a lengthy “but…” segment, and I’m unlikely to challenge that trend. There are some bits that are flat-out excellent, but others which are just flat.
To be honest, a lot of it suffers from the same syndrome I moaned about when I reviewed the early Harry Potter films: The main appeal seems to be the chance to see a beloved story enacted on screen with super-cool special effects. It doesn’t seem to even try and rise to the challenge of providing a new intepretation of the story, it just takes the source material and plonks it up there.
It’s sad, because when it does its own thing, it sometimes works. The opening credits, which aren’t a direct rip from the book, are an excellent way of immersing the viewer in this universe. Admittedly, there’s a bizarre alteration to the ending, which I’m not sure works quite as well. I can see why the original climax would have been tricky, but I’m not sure they’ve thought the new one through.
Also, it has this… austere air to it, this strange conviction that “YOU ARE VIEWING A MASTERPIECE”, I guess because the source material is generally accepted as a masterpiece. Unfortunately, the film clearly isn’t one, so it just seems pretentious.
But despite falling short of masterpiece status, I don’t think it’s bad, or that it deserves the level of outright bile it has generating in some quarters. It’s not as good as the book, but few things are. I don’t think it’s worthless, or even especially bad, I certainly don’t agree with the claims that the story is incomprehensible if you haven’t read the comic. Yes, it requires some concentration, and maybe people aren’t used to that in superhero films, but all the necessary material is there. Some of the performances are excellent, others less so, and yes, the large blue penis is hard to ignore.
In short, it’s an interesting experiment, which hasn’t entirely succeeded. These, of course, are the things which view the most column inches on the internet. See, here I started off intending to produce a relatively concise couple of paragraphs and have ended up rattling off around 500 words. Dammit. Never mind.